Turkey

Mark posing before a glacier's edge? In Turkey?

Mark posing before a glacier’s edge? In Turkey?

This just proves that you can travel the world for years and still come across something utterly unique, something you’ve just never seen before.

From Izmir we went about 135 miles southeast to Pamukkale, still enjoying the Turkish bus system. Pamukkale has been a destination for thousands of years because of the way a couple dozen hot springs create, as the guide book says, “travertines” – as though anyone has a clue what a travertine is. But it was supposed to be a one-of-a-kind sight, and it is adjacent to the ruins of the ancient city of Hieropolis, so we went.

Even after getting there, we weren’t sure what the deal was. You sit in the town and you can see this whitish stuff kind of coming down over the hillside across the road. Still, what’s the big deal?

Sure looks like a snow covered hill to me

Sure looks like a snow covered hill to me

Unlike anything we've ever seen

Unlike anything we’ve ever seen

Well. After lunch we decided to hike up to the ruins and then down through these “travertines” to see what the fuss was all about. Super cool. As Wikipedia describes it, travertine is a form of limestone deposited by mineral springs, especially hot springs. It can be white, tan, creamy, or even rust colored. The water from the hot springs around Pamukkale (Turkish for “Cotton Castle”) spill out over the hill and as the water cools the minerals are left behind. Over thousands of years it creates this wild, crazy winter wonderland-looking walk down the hill.

This has also been a great example of how attention to our historic legacy can bring about positive change. Through history this wasn’t just a geological oddity; the thermal waters were believed to be therapeutic, and from the time of ancient Greeks people have been coming here to “take the cure.” As recently as 50 years ago, though, there were hotels up on the hill using the hot springs for their pools, and motorbikes were driving up and down the slopes. The combination was draining the hot springs, destroying the remains of the ancient city, and ruining the travertines.

In 1988, then, UNESCO declared it a World Heritage Site and Turkey took action. They tore the hotels down and removed the roads that ran up the slopes. They even prohibited people from wearing shoes while walking up and down the hill; you have to go barefoot.

And it all worked. Now it’s a glorious, festive area, with hundreds of people going up and down, playing in the pools created both naturally and by hand. It was so unusual, so crazy, that after walking through it our first afternoon and evening, we went back up the next morning to do it again.

Ruins in Hieropolis are everywhere, including half exposed on a walkway through the site

Ruins in Hieropolis are everywhere, including half exposed on a walkway through the site

Oh, and Hieropolis. The ancient city was founded as a thermal spa some 4,000 years ago. In Roman times the Apostle Phillip spent his last years here, and was reported to have been martyred on a hill overlooking modern Pamukkale. Our tour of the ruins included his “martyrion” along with a really great theater, probably built under the reign of Hadiran and one of the most remarkable ancient restorations we’ve seen anywhere.

The theater of Hieropolis

The theater of Hieropolis

While admiring the remains of the theater I was reminded of our visit to the Pergamon Museum in Berlin, which displays reconstructed monumental buildings like the Pergamon Altar and the Market Gate of Miletus. As much as I enjoyed seeing them in Berlin, I kept thinking “Shouldn’t these be at their original sites?” Well, here at Hieropolis, as in Ephesus, these monumental structures are in their original sites and it is where they belong.

Finally, just a word on how lucky we are to be able to pass leisurely through Turkey like this. Most people, if they get to Pamukkale and Hieropolis at all, do it as a day trip, a quick hop off the bus, walk around, and back on. We were able to spend two days there and go back just because we really enjoyed our first walk through. That’s the luxury of time.

People have been coming to the area to retire - and eventually die - for thousands of years, so there are lots of sarcophagi around. This was in a cute little museum adjacent to the ruins and reminded us how amazing it is that these huge burial chambers were cut out of a single piece of stone. Pretty amazing, when you think about it.

People have been coming to the area to retire – and eventually die – for thousands of years, so there are lots of sarcophagi around. This was in a cute little museum adjacent to the ruins and reminded us how amazing it is that these huge burial chambers were cut out of a single piece of stone. Pretty amazing, when you think about it.

Mark, on the entry to the tour through the ruins. That hedge behind him was rosemary, enough to last you a lifetime.

Mark, on the entry to the tour through the ruins. That hedge behind him was rosemary, enough to last you a lifetime.

The latrines of Hieropolis. Seriously.

The latrines of Hieropolis. Seriously.

Steps up to the hill where the Apostle Phillip was martyred

Steps up to the hill where the Apostle Phillip was martyred

One more shot of the amazing theater

One more shot of the amazing theater

Also next to the ruins is a pool fed by the hot springs. They've tossed a bunch of old columns and stuff in it so you can swim through ancient ruins.

Also next to the ruins is a pool fed by the hot springs. They’ve tossed a bunch of old columns and stuff in it so you can swim through ancient ruins.

Fun!

Fun!

Sunset over the travertines

Sunset over the travertines

Going, going …

Going, going …

Sure looks like he's standing barefoot in the snow. For what it's worth, the shoe was someone else's.

Sure looks like he’s standing barefoot in the snow. For what it’s worth, the shoe was someone else’s.

I was there, too

I was there, too

A small part of the long boardwalk along the coast of Izmir. It's lined with bars, cafés, and restaurants that, I'm confident, were pretty bad. I was amused to note the absence of a railing or other barrier for miles; I don't think that would pass muster in much of the U.S.

A small part of the long boardwalk along the coast of Izmir. It’s lined with bars, cafés, and restaurants that, I’m confident, were pretty bad. I was amused to note the absence of a railing or other barrier for miles; I don’t think that would pass muster in much of the U.S.

Why would anyone go to Izmir, willingly at least? It’s a port on the Mediterranean, but there are no great beaches in or near the city. It’s smack in the center of the great Greek and Roman civilizations, but there are no eye-popping ruins. A century ago it was a great multi-cultural melting pot, but much of that was destroyed in the Great Fire of 1922.

These are just some of the bus companies operating at the Izmir bus stop. We're getting around Turkey on buses and dolmas, minibuses that ply secondary routes. The system is comprehensive and the buses have been really good. But gee, how many bus companies do they need? A lot, apparently.

These are just some of the bus companies operating at the Izmir bus stop. We’re getting around Turkey on buses and dolmas, minibuses that ply secondary routes. The system is comprehensive and the buses have been really good. But gee, how many bus companies do they need? A lot, apparently.

We loved this sign on one of the dolmas we took. Would that everyone took that advice in public places.

We loved this sign on one of the dolmas we took. Would that everyone took that advice in public places.

Turns out that’s a question I asked 40 years ago when the ship I was on, home-ported in Naples, sailed to Izmir for a couple of weeks. I mean, no one’s even heard of Izmir! At the time I didn’t understand it, but I have a little better sense of it now. Izmir, you see, was known as Smyrna for many centuries and it was one of most important ports in the eastern Mediterranean. So yeah, no one’s ever heard of Izmir, but Smyrna was a major city for many hundreds of years. It played a key role in the Greek-Turk war that followed World War I and that led to the creation of the modern Turkish state. Today, then, it’s Turkey’s third-largest city (after Istanbul and Ankara), and a nice little place to land for a couple of days. To be sure, you don’t need a lot of time to see Izmir, but for a couple days it’s got a little feel of Europe in Anatolia, somewhat more liberal than the rest of Turkey.

The quick history: Smyrna was founded by Greek colonists some 3,000 years ago. The Persians took control, but Alexander the Great recovered it for Greece. Alexander, in fact, is given credit in legend at least for Smyrna/Izmir’s current location; he allegedly had the city moved based on a message he received in a dream nearby. In Roman times it was, along with nearby Ephesus (Izmir is maybe 55 miles north of Ephesus), one of the major cities in Rome’s Asian province.

Fast forward a couple thousand years; Smyrna has been an important center of commerce under the Ottoman Empire. But the Ottomans were on the wrong side of World War I, and in the subsequent treaty the Sultan gave away huge amounts of his Empire. With Western support Greece invaded Anatolia, taking Smyrna on May 15, 1919, and headed up towards Istanbul; it appeared as though even the rump territory ceded to the Ottomans was going to be taken over.

Enter Mustafa Kamal (known to history as Ataturk, Father of the Turks) at the head of the Young Turks. They had effectively gone to war with the Sultan over his capitulation after the War, but now mobilized to stop the Greeks. Surprisingly, just years after having been all but wiped out in World War I, they did in fact stop the Greeks and pushed them back to Smyrna. Kamal’s troops retook Smyrna on September 9, 1922, more than three years after the Greeks had first captured the city; that day is now celebrated as the victory of the Turkish War of Independence.

This is what we loved about Izmir; there was some great food. This dish - grilled meatballs on an eggplant-yoghurt with tomatoes was fabulous. In fact, we had it for lunch all three days we were there!

This is what we loved about Izmir; there was some great food. This dish – grilled meatballs on an eggplant-yoghurt with tomatoes was fabulous. In fact, we had it for lunch all three days we were there!

As long as I'm showing food, here's another meal, dinner this time. Artichoke, more eggplant yoghurt, veggies, and of course some raki.

As long as I’m showing food, here’s another meal, dinner this time. Artichoke, more eggplant yoghurt, veggies, and of course some raki.

Unfortunately – but perhaps not surprisingly, given the realities of war – victory was followed quickly by catastrophe. While the Greeks and Armenians were trying to escape Smyrna (the Armenian Genocide had occurred less than 10 years earlier) an enormous fire started, destroying most of the Old City and killing anywhere from 10,000 to 100,000 people. Surviving Greeks, then, were eventually shipped to Greece as part of the final treaty that ended the war: Greece agreed to send Turkish Muslims to Turkey while Turkey shipped Greek Christians to Greece. Thus little of the genuinely multi-ethnic spirit of Smyrna remains in today’s Izmir.

That’s the city’s story, then. For us, there was one historic site that we enjoyed. The Agora – the central part of the ancient city – was built originally for Alexander the Great, then rebuilt after an earthquake in the second century AD by Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius. At first the site looked pretty boring, particularly after touring Ephesus just days earlier, but eventually we discovered the excavated basement of a great basilica on the site. That was fun, and very photogenic.

The excavated basement of a Byzantine basilica. You can see Mark over on the right admiring the site.

The excavated basement of a Byzantine basilica. You can see Mark over on the right admiring the site.

All in all, Izmir made a nice little stop. There’s a long walkway along the coast that’s pleasant. There’s a huge Culture Park near the center of the city, occupying a big part of what had been the Old City before it was destroyed by the Great Fire, where I spent a few hours reading and watching Izmir go by. There’s a busy market area that I remember from my visit in 1975 (though it seemed a lot less exotic now than it did then, when it was the first time I’d ever seen anything like it). And there was some decidedly good food, which always makes for a place we would like.

Otherwise there’s not that much to do in Izmir; it’s the sort of place that’s probably worth a visit every 40 years or so. The relative low-key nature of our stop may have been a good thing, though, as it gave us time to start thinking seriously about our winter plans. For a while we’ve had a general notion that we would spend the winter in Africa, but now we’re starting to put some meat to those sketchy ideas. It is a little strange, I’ll admit, to be dreaming of Africa while sitting in a café in Izmir, that I can attest that it does happen.

Mark in Izmir's bazaar. This was relatively early in the day, but it gets more lively later on.

Mark in Izmir’s bazaar. This was relatively early in the day, but it gets more lively later on.

There was a little - or a lot - of everything in the bazaar, including a fish market area

There was a little – or a lot – of everything in the bazaar, including a fish market area

An Ottoman clock tower from the start of the 20th century lies at the heart of the city and is often described as the city's emblem

An Ottoman clock tower from the start of the 20th century lies at the heart of the city and is often described as the city’s emblem

Right behind the clock tower is this tiny-but-lovely 18th century mosque

Right behind the clock tower is this tiny-but-lovely 18th century mosque

Most of the grounds of the Agora is either empty or taken up by pieces waiting to be put together: pediments here, capitals over there, lintels in that area, and so on

Most of the grounds of the Agora is either empty or taken up by pieces waiting to be put together: pediments here, capitals over there, lintels in that area, and so on

And finally, just to show you we don't just take pictures of cats, here are some of Izmir's finest dogs. We're amused to observe that in East Asia, stray dogs are all small and uniformly a light brown. Here in Asia Minor the strays are much bigger and varied in design. Just an observation.

And finally, just to show you we don’t just take pictures of cats, here are some of Izmir’s finest dogs. We’re amused to observe that in East Asia, stray dogs are all small and uniformly a light brown. Here in Asia Minor the strays are much bigger and varied in design. Just an observation.

The Library of Celsus, essentially a university of its time and the iconic symbol of Ephesus

The Library of Celsus, essentially a university of its time and the iconic symbol of Ephesus

OK, there’s gonna be a lot of pictures here.

Ephesus: home of the Ephesians to whom Paul wrote that letter, capital of Roman Asia Minor, longtime residence of John the Apostle and allegedly the Virgin Mary, site of Cleopatra & Mark Antony’s rendezvous before their final defeat at Augustus’s hands, and the location of the Temple of Artemis, another of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World. According to the ancient Greek historian Strabo, at the time of Augustus Ephesus was second only to Rome in term of size and importance. And into the 5th and 6th century, Ephesus was the most important Asian city in the Byzantine Empire save for only Constantinople itself. There’s a lot here, and we have pictures of all of it.

And cats.

This little cutie greeted us very shortly after entering the ruins of Ephesus. She wasn't alone.

This little cutie greeted us very shortly after entering the ruins of Ephesus. She wasn’t alone.

It’s worth noting that this was my second visit to Ephesus. In February 1975 the ship I was on sailed to Izmir and a group of us did a day-trip to Ephesus. Nineteen-year-old Jim really didn’t know anything about anything at that time, and so over the last several years I’ve been eager to see it again so I could truly appreciate it. Mission accomplished – I really appreciated it this time. Who knows, maybe I’ll come back again in another 40 years, this time as hopefully spry 99-year-old.

We stayed two nights in Selçuk, a cute little town just a couple miles from the old ruins. Mostly the town serves as a stop for tourists like us who want to see the ruins at Ephesus on more than a day-tour basis, but we enjoyed the town on its own terms. Around the region, though, it’s known for the annual camel wrestling championships, which take place in January. (Seriously. They hold a female camel in heat nearby and male camels wrestle until one of them falls or flees. Strange but apparently true.)

Remains of the Basilica of St. John

Remains of the Basilica of St. John

The 14th century Mosque of Isa Bey sits just below the Basilica of St. John. They appear to coexist peacefully.

The 14th century Mosque of Isa Bey sits just below the Basilica of St. John. They appear to coexist peacefully.

The highlight of Selçuk itself is the remains of the Basilica of St. John, a 6th century church commissioned by the Emperor Justinian on what was believed to be the site of John the Apostle’s tomb. It is known historically that some point after the death of Christ, probably around 55 AD, John left Jerusalem to avoid persecution and came to Ephesus. While here he is believed to have written the Gospel According to John along with three Epistles. He may have been exiled at some point to the island of Patmos where he would have written Revelations, though many believe that was a different John. At any rate, he died in Ephesus (probably the last of the apostles to die) and as Christianity gained in popularity his tomb eventually warranted the Emperor Justinian’s attention.

Cats were here, too

Cats were here, too

Posing, just a couple minutes after having been stung on my finger by a wasp. That hurts!

Posing, just a couple minutes after having been stung on my finger by a wasp. That hurts!

The basilica was massive and the ruins are impressive. What really amazed me, though, looking at the ruins, was the realization that the Basilica of St. John is actually a few years younger than the Hagia Sophia, the former Greek Orthodox cathedral that still stands in Istanbul, though is now a museum rather than a church or a mosque. These ruins stand in mute testimony to the phenomenal endurance of the nearly 1,500-year-old Hagia Sophia.

One more word about St. John and the historic sites here. One site that we didn’t go to was the purported house of the Virgin Mary. According to legend she accompanied John from Jerusalem to Ephesus and died here. Then in the early 19th century a crippled German nun claimed to have a mystical relationship with Mary; in visions, she saw where Mary had lived. A French priest followed her directions and – voila! – a shrine was discovered. Now, the only “evidence” that Mary was ever in Ephesus is that, while on the cross, Jesus told John to take care of his mother. That’s it. From that grew the legend that she must have lived in Ephesus near John and then a mystical nun “found” her house. Given the relative weakness of the case we decided to pass on her house. Oh, and besides that, I went there when I was in Ephesus in 1975, so I already have the picture.

The next morning we headed out to the ruins of Ephesus itself to be there when it opened at 8:30, hoping to miss the worst of the crowds and heat. It was a good move, as the crowds really picked up later in the morning and it got really hot. The chance to walk through the remains of the central city in the cool morning air, with manageable crowds, was really something. We’ve toured a lot of Roman and Greek ruins, but Ephesus might well be the most complete, the most alive, of any we’ve ever seen. You could really get a sense of the scale and grandeur of the place. And when you associate it with the people who walked on the same streets – Alexander the Great, Cleopatra, Mark Antony, Augustus, Hadrian, and on and on – it is genuinely awesome.

The first long stretch very shortly after opening, so no crowds (yet)

The first long stretch very shortly after opening, so no crowds (yet)

The Temple of Hadrian

The Temple of Hadrian

Looking down Curetes Way, the main thoroughfare in Ephesus, toward the Library of Celsus

Looking down Curetes Way, the main thoroughfare in Ephesus, toward the Library of Celsus

Mark's favorite picture from the day, the Library again

Mark’s favorite picture from the day, the Library again

The Great Theater, which seated 25,000

The Great Theater, which seated 25,000

Part way down Curetes Way archeologists have been recovering what are called the Terraced Houses, homes of some of Ephesus’s richest and most prominent citizens. The work there is simply remarkable. They’ve built stairs snaking up and down and around the site so you get a great view of six or seven different houses. It includes some of the most intact ancient mosaics I’ve ever seen and great frescos. You get a real sense of how the houses were laid out and how impressive they were – grand halls, marble walls, even hot and cold baths. It’s a working site, so you can watch people doing their painstaking work to rebuild the ancient wonders. And to top it off (so to speak), the space is all covered by a somewhat translucent roof, making the space pleasantly cool on a day that was getting increasingly hot. They charge an extra few dollars to tour the area and we were very glad to have splurged.

One of the rooms in the Terraced Houses. Note the mosaic floor and frescoed walls.

One of the rooms in the Terraced Houses. Note the mosaic floor and frescoed walls.

A closer view of just one piece of flooring, a lion devouring a lamb. Can't blame him, I like lamb, too.

A closer view of just one piece of flooring, a lion devouring a lamb. Can’t blame him, I like lamb, too.

This is a workspace in the site, where they are apparently piecing together marble walls and mosaic floors. To me it looks like the damnedest jigsaw puzzle ever.

This is a workspace in the site, where they are apparently piecing together marble walls and mosaic floors. To me it looks like the damnedest jigsaw puzzle ever.

Mark up near the top of the Terraced Houses site

Mark up near the top of the Terraced Houses site

Another highlight for me was the Church of Mary, an early 5th century church and supposedly the first church dedicated to Mary. Besides being cool ruins, the church played an important part in the early history of the Catholic Church. It was to this church in 431 AD that Emperor Theodosius summoned the church’s third ecumenical council, the Council of Ephesus. Over several weeks the leaders of the church debated the teachings of Nestorius, the Patriarch of Constantinople, that Mary gave birth to the human Jesus but not the God Jesus. It’s hard for me to understand or really even believe how important this distinction was at the time, but apparently it was a very big deal. Ultimately the council confirmed the Nicene Creed and condemned Nestorius’s teachings. And it all happened here!

Remains of the Church of Mary, where the Council of Ephesus was held

Remains of the Church of Mary, where the Council of Ephesus was held

With all that, we’re till not done with all the great ruins in the area. The Temple of Artemis, another of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World, stood in Ephesus, too. Stood, though, is really the relevant word. Though it once stood proudly with 127 60-foot columns. Today just one remains so, rather than being very wonderful at all it is, the the words of Lonely Planet, “just a 20-second photo opportunity.”

That's what's left of the Temple of Artemis. Pretty impressive, huh?

That’s what’s left of the Temple of Artemis. Pretty impressive, huh?

So that was Ephesus, a pretty great little stop. From here we’re heading north to Izmir, Turkey’s third largest city, for a couple of days and then we’ll continue wandering around Turkey. Here are some more photos that I just couldn’t resist.

A fountain at the top of the Upper Road

A fountain at the top of the Upper Road

Another view of the Library of Celsus

Another view of the Library of Celsus

A closeup of the entrance to the Temple of Hadrian

A closeup of the entrance to the Temple of Hadrian

Mark with that Library as background

Mark with that Library as background

Marble Street, connecting the Library to the Great Theater

Marble Street, connecting the Library to the Great Theater

Harbor Street, connecting the ancient harbor to the Great Theater. When I was here 40 years ago our guide told us that this was the road that Mark Antony came up as he arrived to join forces with his lover Cleopatra for their fight to the finish with Octavius, who would soon become Caesar Augustus.

Harbor Street, connecting the ancient harbor to the Great Theater. When I was here 40 years ago our guide told us that this was the road that Mark Antony came up as he arrived to join forces with his lover Cleopatra for their fight to the finish with Octavius, who would soon become Caesar Augustus.

There's a nice little museum in Selçuk, which included this multi-breasted statue of Artemis

There’s a nice little museum in Selçuk, which included this multi-breasted statue of Artemis

And this huge head and arm from a statue of the Emperor Domitian from the late 1st century AD

And this huge head and arm from a statue of the Emperor Domitian from the late 1st century AD

A highlight of the stay was Ejdar Restaurant, a family-run place with Mom responsible for mezzos, Dad on the grill, and son serving. They say that Bill & Hillary ate here when he was President, so they were pretty impressed when Mark showed them the picture of me with Hillary. Now they think we're Important People.

A highlight of the stay was Ejdar Restaurant, a family-run place with Mom responsible for mezzos, Dad on the grill, and son serving. They say that Bill & Hillary ate here when he was President, so they were pretty impressed when Mark showed them the picture of me with Hillary. Now they think we’re Important People.

This little cutie was watching our dinner closely. And no, she didn't go away hungry.

This little cutie was watching our dinner closely. And no, she didn’t go away hungry.

Mark loves his Turkish coffee, thick enough to eat with a spoon

Mark loves his Turkish coffee, thick enough to eat with a spoon